Page 2 of 2
In the meantime, anyone with something to hide might want to keep in mind a recent decision by the Massachusetts Court of Appeals, which admitted as evidence DNA collected after a suspected rapist spit on the street.
Kristen Sumstad's killer was convicted using D.N.A. evidence.
The DNA Age
Genetic Stakeout
Articles in this series explore the impact of new genetic technology on American life
Previous Articles in the Series »
RSS Feed
Get Science News From The New York Times »
DNA collected from a used cigarette butt linked Rolando Gallego to a bloody towel found at the scene of a 1993 murder.
Readers' Comments
"We cannot continue to hire law officers then hamstring them by cutting off avenues of gaining evidence."
RichL, Portland, Oregon
Read Full Comment »
“We conclude that under the circumstances, the expectorating defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his spittle,” the court ruled, “or in the DNA evidence derived therefrom.”
The United States Supreme Court has yet to address whether there are constitutional limits on the covert collection of DNA. But with a few exceptions, lower court judges in over a dozen recent cases have ruled that DNA clinging to water bottles left in interrogation rooms, on restaurant glassware and on those ubiquitous cigarette butts are fair game for police inspection.
“There is no subjective expectation of privacy in discarded genetic material, just as there is no subjective expectation of privacy in fingerprints or footprints left in a public place,” Washington State’s Supreme Court wrote last year in denying an appeal by John N. Athan, whose murder conviction was based on surreptitiously collected DNA. Seattle police detectives posing as a law firm sent Mr. Athan a letter on fake stationery, asking him to join a lawsuit to recover overcharged parking tickets, of which they knew he had had many. DNA from saliva on the envelope that he sent back matched a semen sample from the 1982 murder and rape of a 13-year-old Seattle girl.
In a dissenting opinion, Justice Mary E. Fairhurst argued that the fingerprint analogy was inappropriate, because Mr. Athan’s DNA “provided the government with vast amounts of intimate information beyond mere identity” including race, gender, predisposition to disease and, perhaps, forms of conduct.
But Tim Bradshaw, a senior prosecuting attorney in King County, Wash., who worked on the case, said he had received calls from prosecutors around the country eager to employ a similar DNA ruse. (Courts generally allow the police to use all sorts of deception to obtain evidence from people they suspect of committing crimes.)
“The success of it has emboldened investigators, and it should,” Mr. Bradshaw said. “Just because something is very clever doesn’t make it illegitimate.”
In Los Angeles, a Superior Court judge last year rejected a motion by attorneys for a suspected serial killer, Adolph Laudenberg, to suppress DNA evidence that the police had acquired by inviting him to a doughnut shop to discuss an unrelated case. One detective set aside Mr. Laudenberg’s Styrofoam coffee cup, and an undercover officer retrieved it.
Several court opinions on surreptitious sampling cite the United States Supreme Court decision in California v. Greenwood, which held that the Fourth Amendment did not apply when the police searched trash bags left on the curb by a suspected narcotics dealer.
But the Greenwood analogy, critics of surreptitious sampling argue, ignores that most people have no idea that they risk surrendering their genetic identity to the police by, for instance, failing to destroy a used coffee cup. Moreover, even if they do realize it, there is no way to avoid abandoning one’s DNA in public, short of living in a bubble.
“Unlike garbage that can be withheld or destroyed before it is released into the world,” reads the motion to suppress the DNA evidence in the Gallego case, “we cannot do so with our biological tissues.”
A few courts have found that certain forms of surreptitious sampling do violate the Fourth Amendment.
DNA from a water bottle given to a suspected rapist, for instance, was deemed inadmissible in an Iowa court because a police officer had swapped the suspect’s water with a similar bottle when the man went to the bathroom. He retained a reasonable expectation of privacy, the court ruled, because he had not “abandoned” it.
And last year, the North Carolina Court of Appeals ordered a new trial for Blake J. Reed, a convicted burglar, because a police officer kicked a cigarette butt off his patio and later picked it up. The court said Mr. Reed had an expectation of privacy at home.
Suspects may be wising up. After smoking another cigarette on the patio, Mr. Reed took apart the butt, removed the filter’s wrapper and shredded it, according to court documents. He had seen the popular television show “CSI,” where DNA often nails the suspect, he told the detective. Then he placed the remains in his pocket.
Defense Lawyers Fight DNA Samples Gained on Sly
Posted by Jeyaganeshan on Sunday, September 26, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
DNA
0 comments:
Post a Comment