In 2007, a reporter for the Post & Courier of Charleston, S.C., was tired of doing straight stories on hurricane forecasts. So he hired a medium to predict the forthcoming storm season. “The sense we got from emergency-management people here,” the reporter wrote, “is that the forecasts had been so wrong that they were hearing from the public, ‘Why should we pay any attention to this stuff?’”
University of Massachusetts researcher Jon Woodruff putters his plastic boat near enough to the rest of his team so the others can hear when X marks the spot. Slowly, he relays the string of numbers: 30.01136N and 84.42989W. Sam Zipper, a research assistant from Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute, enters them into his GPS device and directs us west and then north.
Dana McDonald, another Woods Hole researcher, and I row the pond-worthy vessel — two aluminum canoes with a square of plywood lashed between them — making a few passes until we’re over the right coordinates. McDonald sets three anchors to hold the ungainly catamaran against the cutting wind on this uncommonly cold 27-degree morning in St. Mark’s National Wildlife Refuge, 25 miles south of Tallahassee along Florida’s Gulf Coast.
Woodruff and fellow principal investigator Jeff Donnelly of Woods Hole are seeking sediment samples, long tubes of sand, muck and other material that serve as a muddy analog to tree rings, giving evidence of weather and other physical phenomena going back thousands of years. The deeper into the muck they can drill, the longer the historical record. Each core is like a many-layered cake. They’re looking for thin white slivers in the dark peat revealing major storms that picked up sand and deposited it far inland.
Greg Holland, the director of the Mesoscale and Microscale Meteorologyprogram at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colo., and one of the éminences grises of the hurricane forecasting community, says that 20 years ago, predicting the track of hurricanes headed toward land wasn’t terribly reliable. Then a burst of research dramatically improved these real-time forecasts. He sees the same thing happening now with forecasting hurricane frequency and intensity, years and even decades in advance. “It’s a rapidly evolving field,” he says. “There’s this intensive effort. You can see the curve bending down towards better and more precise predictions. It’s an exciting time.”
Last summer, Congress held hearings and called for a national hurricane research initiative similar to one that exists for earthquakes, which have caused only a fraction of the economic losses that hurricanes have in the U.S. in recent years. Nearly 30 million Americans live in coastal areas, from North Carolina to Texas, that are threatened by hurricanes. More than 3,000 people have died since 2003 in hurricanes. The National Science Board estimates that from 2002 to 2007, economic losses due to hurricanes totaled $180 billion. According to the Reinsurance Association of America, insured property exposure is $9 trillion. AIR Worldwide, a catastrophe modeling company, estimates that disaster losses will double every decade because of growing residential and commercial density along the coasts.
Every spring, researchers from Colorado State University, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and the Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies at Florida State University issue forecasts for the coming hurricane season. They rely mostly on statistical models guided by recent history.
None projects hurricanes beyond the next season. Risk Management Solutions, a company that helps insurers manage their exposure from natural disasters, took a stab in 2006, issuing a five-year forecast predicting that insured hurricane losses in the United States would be 40 percent higher than the historical average. The projection has been a colossal bust, greatly overestimating losses.
Holland and others, including Roger Pielke Jr., director of the Center for Science and Technology Policy Research at the University of Colorado and a senior fellow at the Breakthrough Institute, a progressive think tank, say the current seasonal forecasts exhibit no more skill than Punxsutawney Phil predicting the end of winter. “These efforts to predict are scientifically worthwhile exploring and add to the understanding of hurricane dynamics,” Pielke says. “But from the standpoint of being practical, skillful and useful, they are not there yet, and, who knows, they may never be.”
Part of the record-breaking 2005 season, Dennis was the second punch to Florida’s northwest coast. Nine months earlier, Hurricane Ivan, nicknamed Ivan the Terrible, landed a left hook with 130 mph winds and extensive flooding, although the major damage was further west in Santa Rosa County and Pensacola, where the storm surge reached 15 feet. The storm destroyed a quarter mile of the bridge across Escambia Bay. At sea, Ivan sunk seven oil rigs and set five others adrift. Even more costly was the damage to underwater pipelines. Some were moved 3,000 feet while others were lost, buried under 30 feet of mud, according to a study by the United StatesNaval Research Laboratory. A monitoring buoy 100 miles south of Mobile, Ala., recorded a wave of more than 53 feet as Ivan approached. The hurricane killed 14 people in Florida and caused $13 billion in damages across the southern United States. (Three other hurricanes — Charley, Frances and Jeanne — struck other parts of Florida in 2004).
Franklin W. Nutter, president of the Reinsurance Association of America, says the industry has been encouraging and funding research on three main fronts: longer-term regional forecasts looking to understand the effects of climate change, a better understanding of storm surges in coastal areas and better forecasts of storm intensity. “There are so many unresolved questions,” he says.
Better forecasting would give insurers, homeowners and policymakers an opportunity to adapt by changing land-use policies, strengthening building codes and preserving or restoring natural mitigation by wetlands, floodplains, and beach and dune systems. Several studies have shown investing in better forecasting and mitigation has significant returns. One study by the Multihazard Mitigation Council of the National Institute of Building Sciences concluded that each dollar spent on mitigation saves an average of $4 in damage costs.
Anecdotal information about hurricanes goes back a few hundred years but is considered unreliable until the last century or so. In 1943, the “Surprise Hurricane” (the current naming system wasn’t in place) struck Texas. British pilots were being trained for World War II at Bryan Field in College Station. When they saw Americans evacuating their AT-6 Texan trainers, they chided them about the plane’s durability. The lead instructor, Col. Joseph Duckworth, hopped into a trainer and flew into the storm. After Duckworth returned safely, the base’s weather officer, Lt. William Jones-Burdick, demanded he be taken into the storm. Soon, there were regular flights through hurricanes to gather meteorological data.
In 1984, William Gray, a meteorologist and professor at Colorado State University, issued the first seasonal hurricane forecast, predicting that 10 tropical storms and five hurricanes — existing for a total of 30 “hurricane days” — would strike the Atlantic and Caribbean basins.
Three main factors, NOAA meteorologist Gerry Bell says, influence the number of hurricanes. They are the El Niño/La Niña cycle in the Pacific Ocean; what are known as multidecadal cycles, 25-to-40-year periods of higher or lower hurricane activity (we’ve been in a higher activity phase since 1995); and Atlantic Ocean temperatures. “Based on the climate patterns and their combined strength, we have a variety of statistical tools that say given this set of climate conditions, what historically have we seen?” Bell says. “You would say this combination has produced anywhere from 13 to 16 named storms or three to five hurricanes, things like that. Based on historical record, you can go back and link these climate conditions to level of activity.”
The most severe hurricanes are so rare that it’s almost impossible to detect a pattern in their occurrence. Only three Category 5 storms have pounded American shores in the last century: Hurricane Andrew, which killed 23 when it struck Florida and Louisiana in 1992, Hurricane Camille, which plowed through Mississippi in 1969, and an unnamed storm that smashed through the Florida Keys in 1935.
In 2007, a Woodruff-Donnelly paper in Nature reported that a Playa Grande, Puerto Rico, sediment core revealed a 5,000-year storm record that identified weak El Niños and strong monsoons in West Africa as key factors that heightened Atlantic hurricane activity and that should be incorporated into computer models.
Last year, in another Nature paper, the researchers reported that the frequency of intense hurricanes in the Atlantic over the past 1,500 years has been closely linked to changes in El Niño and sea surface temperatures. The work suggested that a warming world may face more intense hurricanes, something that has become a consensus among scientists starting to analyze the data from computer models. The past decade, they noted, had the highest number of North Atlantic hurricanes since a similar period 1,000 years ago when El Niños were also weak and sea surface temperatures were high.
When he went to Japan for the first time to meet his future in-laws, Woodruff dragged them and his parents to a small island 12 miles southwest of the main island to dig in the muck. On a return trip in 2006, he drafted his wife and mother-in-law for long days of pulling sediment cores from jellyfish-infested waters onto a craft named The Unsinkable, fashioned from two Wal-Mart rafts. (It wasn’t, by the way.) His Japan work formed the basis for his doctoral thesis, the first long-term coring record for North Pacific typhoons.
Woodruff found his research passion in the mud while earning a master’s degree and doctorate in a joint Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Woods Hole program. He has a reputation as being the team’s MacGyver, someone who can fashion tools from this and that in the field. He’s made boats out of children’s toy rafts and a beer cooler.
The area is ideal for such research because hurricane strikes are common, storm surges are high and the sinkhole ponds offer the possibility of deep sedimentary records. Using Google Earth, Woods Hole researcher Phil Lane identified more than 100 potential ponds to scout. One night, after dinner in the cinderblock beachfront dormitory of Florida State University’s Coastal and Marine Laboratory on St. James Island, the team sits at tables arranged in a T, poring over map printouts and the computerized results of ground-penetrating radar and sonar scouting expeditions.
Back in Massachusetts two weeks later, Woodruff notes that a previous core 6 meters long contained a historical record covering 4,000 years. How far back the layers in the Lake Patricia core will transport researchers depends upon the rate of sedimentation. More rapid deposition means a shorter record, but more detail. It will take months to begin radiocarbon dating the core and perhaps a couple of years to analyze it. “Each of these lakes is recording hurricanes in slightly different fashion. You sort of have to get a feel for how to read the book,” Woodruff says. “It’s a slow process, and there are few eureka moments.”
For quicker answers, there’s always the local medium.
0 comments:
Post a Comment